Time to Pay arrangements with HMRC: how to improve your chances of success

If your company has fallen behind with its tax payments, a Time to Pay arrangement with HMRC is often the first option to consider. In our experience, the arrangements that succeed have three things in common: the directors approached HMRC early, they understood their numbers, and they were honest about what the business could afford.

In brief

  • A Time to Pay arrangement spreads overdue company tax over monthly instalments. Several taxes can usually be included.
  • HMRC normally expects arrangements for business taxes to run for less than 12 months. Longer periods are possible but exceptional.
  • Interest is charged throughout, so paying sooner costs less.
  • A strong arrangement is based on up-to-date figures, a realistic forecast, and an understanding of what went wrong and what needs to be done to bring things back on track.
  • Alongside the arrangement, HMRC will expect all ongoing taxes to be paid as they fall due and tax returns to be kept up to date.
  • If a payment is going to be missed, contact HMRC before it happens.
  • Time to Pay suits a business that can afford to repay. Where the debt is too large, look at the other options early.

What is a Time to Pay arrangement

A Time to Pay arrangement is a payment plan agreed with HMRC. Instead of settling overdue tax in one payment, your company repays it in monthly instalments. VAT, PAYE and corporation tax can usually be dealt with together. If a new bill arrives that you can’t pay, contact HMRC straight away. It may be possible to add it to the arrangement, but this isn’t automatic, and HMRC is likely to review whether the arrangement is still realistic.

HMRC’s public guidance sets no fixed time limit, but HMRC will want the debt repaid as quickly as you can afford. For business taxes, arrangements are expected to run for less than 12 months. HMRC’s internal guidance treats anything longer as exceptional, needing greater scrutiny and a clear reason.

Interest is charged throughout, so paying sooner costs less. Once an arrangement is agreed, HMRC will normally let it run its course as long as you keep to its terms. It can withdraw if those terms are broken or your position changes.

HMRC will also expect you to reduce the debt where you reasonably can, for example by selling assets, and may ask whether directors can put in funds or arrange borrowing.

What will HMRC want to see?

HMRC’s central question is whether the arrangement will work. For smaller debts repaid over a few months, an arrangement is often agreed over the phone after HMRC has asked about your income and outgoings. For larger debts or longer periods, HMRC may require a clear understanding of your financial position, the forecasts that support your proposal, and the assumptions behind them.

Before you contact HMRC

  • Bring your bookkeeping up to date.
  • Prepare a forecast of what the business can afford each month, after ongoing taxes and costs.
  • Be clear on the total owed, by tax and period.
  • Identify what caused the arrears and what you are doing to address it.
  • Make sure all current tax returns have been filed.
  • Consider whether assets, refinancing or money owed to you could reduce the debt.

Why the forecast matters

A forecast is not something to prepare only if HMRC asks for it. It is how you work out what you can genuinely afford, after future taxes, running costs and any costs of restructuring or refinancing. If you don’t have one, now is the time to prepare it, even in a basic form.

It will often show exactly what went wrong and what needs to change. And if refinancing is part of the plan, any lender funding a settlement with HMRC will want credible figures showing the business can afford the repayments.

Offer what you can genuinely afford. A lump sum helps, because it reduces interest, but it isn’t required at the outset. If money is on its way, for example from refinancing, an asset sale or overdue customer payments, an arrangement can start with modest payments, with the planned increase written into its terms.

You may be confident preparing all this yourself. Many directors work on it with their accountant or bookkeeper. Where the debt is substantial or the position is complex, a business recovery adviser can help.

Where to start

Smaller debts can sometimes be set up using HMRC’s online payment plan service. Otherwise, contact HMRC about payment problems. HMRC’s full guidance is at If you cannot pay your tax bill on time.

How do I keep the arrangement on track?

In our experience, arrangements most often fail because circumstances change and HMRC isn’t told. Alongside your instalments, HMRC will expect you to pay all ongoing taxes as they fall due and keep your tax returns up to date.

Be open and accurate with HMRC. If you need more time to review your figures or take advice, ask for it, and ask for it to be noted on HMRC’s records. Each call is also a chance to understand where your case sits, what HMRC expects and whether its records are complete. Keep a note of the date, who you spoke to and what was agreed, as you will often speak to someone different each time.

What if I can’t make a payment?

Contact HMRC before the payment is due. Explain why, and when you expect to be back on track. A short, explained delay is usually manageable, especially if everything else is up to date.

Problems arise when payments are missed without explanation, when it becomes a pattern, or when HMRC’s calls go unanswered. A broken arrangement means starting again, with a record that makes the next conversation harder.

You can take advice at any stage: when preparing your first proposal, after a rejection, or simply when things feel complex or uncertain.

When isn’t Time to Pay the right answer?

Time to Pay works well when the business underneath is sound and can fund repayments while meeting its ongoing costs. HMRC is generally willing to agree it, because it gets the debt paid.

Time to Pay deals with arrears that have already built up. It does not fix a business that is still losing money. If losses continue, they need to be addressed first, or the arrears will simply return.

It is less suitable when the debt is large compared with what the business can realistically repay. Under pressure, directors can commit to payments or timescales that were never achievable, sometimes backed by their own savings.

Case example

A company owed HMRC £150,000. To secure an arrangement, the director put in £30,000 of personal savings, without a forecast or a clear view of what recovery would require. Within a few months the company fell behind again, the arrangement failed and the company entered insolvency. The savings that could have supported a planned transition, or a new start, had been spent.

Before putting in personal money, take advice on the alternatives. Depending on the circumstances, these might include a company voluntary arrangement (a formal agreement to repay creditors what the business can afford over an agreed period) or closing the company in an orderly way. In some cases, restarting the business in a structured, transparent way is the more sustainable route. A restart must be handled properly, with professional advice from a licensed insolvency practitioner.

The earlier you look at the options, the more of them remain open.

Where can I get help?

Your accountant knows your business and its figures, and is often a good first conversation. You are also welcome to contact us directly, and we will involve your accountant where they are already advising you.

We are business recovery specialists and licensed insolvency practitioners. Our support falls into three areas.

Preparing the proposal. We can help you build or review your forecast, establish what is affordable, and deal with HMRC alongside you or on your behalf. We can also revisit a proposal that has been rejected or an arrangement that has broken down.

Strengthening it. Tax arrears are often a symptom of a wider cashflow problem. Our commercial finance team can look at refinancing assets to fund a settlement, including where your existing lender can’t help. If customers are paying late, our debt recovery team can help recover what you are owed.

Testing it against the alternatives. We look at the other options alongside any Time to Pay proposal. That shows you whether the arrangement is the best route, and it can strengthen your case with HMRC by setting out what it would be likely to receive if the arrangement were not agreed.

We do not provide tax advice. We work with your accountant and tax adviser, who should review the tax position.

If you’re an accountant supporting a client in this position, we’re happy to talk it through with you, whether or not a referral follows.

Falling behind with HMRC is stressful, but it is a situation most businesses can work through, particularly when it is dealt with early and with accurate figures. If you would like to talk it through, speak to your accountant or contact us for a free initial consultation.